Four Episcopal bishops who were sent on a special mission to
El Salvador have returned with one common message -- continue the
pressure for release of church workers held by the government and find
new ways to express solidarity with churches being persecuted.
Bishops William Frey of Colorado, William Swing of California,
David Reed of Kentucky, and James Ottley of Panama were sent to El
Salvador by Presiding Bishop Edmond Browning after government forces
conducted a predawn raid on November 20 at St. John the Evangelist
Church in San Salvador and seized 21 church workers, including the
church's rector, the Rev. Luis Serrano. Browning and a dozen other
church leaders in the United States issued a statement on November 29
declaring their "outrage over the deliberate and calculated campaign
by government forces in El Salvador to intimidate and harass the
churches in that country" and criticizing U.S. government policy as
insufficient. After Bishops Frey and Reed were turned back at the airport in
San Salvador, and while Bishop Swing waited in Miami for his visa, the
Episcopal Church expressed its disapproval of the Salvadoran
government's handling of these matters to Salvadoran diplomats in the
United States, and Browning sent a fax message to President Cristiani
of El Salvador. Cristiani apologized for the "inconveniences" and
promised that the bishops would be allowed to enter the country.
"All the doors were opened to us after the deportation
incident," Bishop Ottley reported to colleagues at the Episcopal
Church Center on his return. Ottley said that the bishops spent twohours meeting with Cristiani, met with the American ambassador, and
were able to visit several of the Episcopal church workers in jail,
including Serrano. Ottley said that Serrano was in good spirits and
was not being mistreated, although other jailed church workers had
obviously been beaten. Serrano told the bishops that his only sin was
"working with the poor" and that the government would not be able to
substantiate its charges that he knew about a truck belonging to
guerillas being loaded with ammunition on the grounds of his church.
A civilian judge must decide if Serrano will be tried, but
Ottley said that the church workers were "optimistic they will not go
to trial and will be released soon."
As a graphic reminder of the inherent danger of the mission,
the bishops were awakened in the middle of the night by machine-gun
fire and mortars, according to Bishop Reed's diary. After some
restless sleep, the bishops met on December 7 with diocesan leaders,
and the vice minister of foreign affairs and attended a two-hour
meeting with Salvadoran president Alfredo Cristiani. The bishops
tried to convince President Cristiani said that the charges were not
valid, and the Salvadoran leader and promised to "look into the
matter," denying that there was any systematic attempt to persecute
the churches. Bishop Reed led a prayer "that all might find the peace
that was God's will."
Bishop Swing said in an interview that the bishops had tried
to let Cristiani know that the international churches were monitoring
the situation and that the pressure on his government would continue
to build. Swing came away from the meeting with the feeling that
Cristiani did not understand the small Protestant churches in El
Salvador and might have underestimated the international protests.
At the end of the day, the bishops met with three of the
Episcopal prisoners. "The presence of four bishops in purple shirts
in the office of the commandante of the prison made a real impact,"
Bishop Reed said in his diary. "It was worth all that we had gone
through to get there."
Demilitarization is the first step"This situation is too complex to put on a bumper sticker,"
Bishop Frey said in a phone interview. "I came away with more
questions than answers," he added. "There is just no infrastructure
for peace -- and that must be changed before anything else can happen.
We may be looking at a problem that has no solution in the foreseeable
future," he said. The bishops agreed that the first step toward peace in El
Salvador is demilitarization, "taking away the toys and then talking,"
as Frey put it. "All these groups wielding guns have their own
definitions of justice," added Swing, who finds some hope in the
recent meetings of the five Central American presidents and their
attempts to demilitarize the region. Swing said that "it
[demilitarization] can be done," and he pointed to Costa Rica as a
good model. The bishops all agreed that some continuing presence was
important. They indicated a willingness to make another trip in the
future, if the Presiding Bishop should find that it would be helpful.
Ottley said that the visit of the bishops "may help ease the pressure
for the time being," but he added that he thinks the future of the
Episcopal Church may be at stake and that it may be necessary to form
a group that would be "ready to respond quickly" as the situation
continues to change. Presiding Bishop Browning told the bishops in a conference
call after their return that his recent conversations with U.S. and
Salvadoran officials in Washington, D.C., suggested that the first step is for the United States and the Soviet Union to stop sending in
arms so that the cycle of violence can be broken. He also restated
his intention to challenge current U.S. policy in Latin America. Episcopal Church confronts Salvadorans on church persecutionThe bishops' trip was part of a continuing confrontation by
the Episcopal Church and other church bodies over the threat to
churches and church workers in El Salvador. At a press conference
held on November 21, the day after the Episcopal church workers had
been seized, Browning called for a "reassessment of our government's
policy in Latin America from top to bottom," and said that the U.S.
government should be doing everything in its power to stop the
hostilities in El Salvador. "I really believe that the religious
community has to continue in every way possible to put pressure both
on our government and the government of El Salvador to bring about a
release of the tension and a greater sense of peace and justice,"
Browning said in his statement. A week later, one of the Episcopal church workers, Josephine
Beecher, was released, and flown to the United States. She reported
to Browning in New York and held a news conference (see ENS 89248).
Beecher had been seized in the November 20 raid at St. John the
Evangelist Church and, while in detention, was blindfolded,
handcuffed, and beaten. "The U.S. government should not be funding
the atrocities and murders in El Salvador," she said in her criticism
of the close ties the United States maintains with the Salvadoran
military regime. Beecher said that the Salvadoran military was trying
to destroy the Episcopal Church in the country by depriving it of
leadership during this critical time. Browning sought an appointment with President George Bush.
When that was not possible, he and 10 other church leaders met in
Washington with House Speaker Thomas Foley, Senator Claiborne Pell of
the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, and officials at the State Department to express their growing concern for the safety of church
workers in El Salvador. Browning expressed his disappointment that
the group couldn't meet Bush but said that the Speaker was "very open
to our concerns about religious persecution and religious freedom" and
planned a response. Signs of a national campaign of concernConcern for the safety of the church workers in El Salvador
and criticism of U.S. policy is producing a nationwide campaign. For example, the National Council of Churches (NCC) has
launched a human-rights campaign to call attention to the harassment
of church workers, which will culminate in ecumenical services across
the nation on January 21. It has asked churches to place purple
ribbons on their doors and leave them there until all imprisoned
church leaders are released. The NCC has also asked its members to
contact congressional representatives and encourage them to work to
"guarantee safety and immediate freedom for imprisoned church
workers," obtain a negotiated settlement to the civil war, and seek an
end to U. S. military assistance to the Salvadoran military. Churches in major cities across the nation are organizing
protest marches. Bishop H. Coleman McGhee of Michigan participated in
and spoke at a memorial service in Detroit for the Jesuits, Archbishop
Oscar Romero, and "the other 70,000 who have been killed since the
beginning of this conflict." In Washington, D.C., Episcopalian, Lutheran, and American
Baptist leaders held a news conference and issued a joint statement
pointing out that "those who help the poor are being targeted with
death threats and treated as enemies of the government." The church
leaders presented their statement to the Salvadoran ambassador (see
photo). In Minnesota, a group of eight, including the husband of a
member of the Episcopal Church, began a fast on Thanksgiving Day at
the Roman Catholic Cathedral in St. Paul seeking an end to U.S.military aid to El Salvador. The strikers chose to begin their fast
at the Cathedral because in El Salvador the church acts as "a voice
for the voiceless, a place of refuge and sanctuary." They have formed
an organization called Ecumenical Fast for El Salvador in Churches and
Temples (EFFECT), which is sponsoring a number of events in other
cities. It issued a statement on December 15 calling on "all people
of faith and conscience" to pray and fast and come to Washington on
January 23 to January 25 for a nationwide mobilization for peace in El
Salvador. The religious community in Hartford, Connecticut, held an
ecumenical service "in solidarity with the persecuted church in El
Salvador" at St. Joseph's Cathedral (see related story). The Boston Religious Task Force, an interfaith coalition
organized in response to the murder of the Jesuit priests, is holding
a "service of renewal" to coincide with the opening of Congress. The
Interreligious Task Force is conducting a fast and vigil at noon every
day on the steps of the Episcopal cathedral in Boston. |