Resolution Number: 2022-D040
Title: Refer a Resolution on Canons IV.13.4, IV 13.11(e), IV.13.13 {Of Hearing Panels],and IV.14.6 [Of Accords and Orders]
Legislative Action Taken: Referred
Final Text:

Resolved, That the 80th General Convention amend Canon IV.13.4 to read as follows:

Sec. 4. If at any time after a matter has been referred to a Hearing Panel an Accord or Order of Dismissal endorsed by the Bishop Diocesan is reached that ends the proceedings before the Hearing Panel issues an Order, the Bishop Diocesan shall make the Notice of Accord or Order of Dismissal available to the Church and Church media as provided in Sec. 3 as well as to the Hearing Panel.

And be it further

Resolved, That Canon IV.13.11.e be amended to read as follows:

e. If an Accord is reached or the matter is dismissed that ends the proceedings before the Disciplinary Board issues an Order other than an Order of Dismissal under this Section, the Bishop Diocesan shall make the Notice of Accord or Order of Dismissal available to the Church and Church media as provided in Sec. 3 as well as to the Disciplinary Board and the Hearing Panel.

And be it further

Resolved, That Canon IV.13.13 be amended to read as follows:

Section 13.  If the determination is to dismiss the matter, the Hearing Panel shall issue an Order which shall include the reasons for dismissal and which contains may contain findings exonerating the Respondent.  A copy of the Order shall be provided to the Bishop Diocesan, the Respondent, the Respondent’s Advisor, the Complainant, the Complainant’s Advisor, and the Church Attorney, and a record copy of the Order shall be kept by transmitting a copy to The Archives of The Episcopal Church.  A copy of the Order shall also be made available to the Church and the Church media in the same manner with which documents were initially made available to the public as set forth in Sec. 3.

And be it further

Resolved, That IV.13.14 be removed in its entirety.

Sec. 14. If the resolution is the issuance of an Order other than an Order of dismissal, the provisions of Canon IV.14 shall apply.

And be it further

Resolved, That Canon IV.14.6 be amended to read as follows:

Sec. 6. An Order issued by a Conference Panel or Hearing Panel may (a) provide any terms which promote healing, repentance, forgiveness, restitution, justice, amendment of life and reconciliation among the Complainant, Respondent, affected Community and other persons; (b) place restrictions on the Respondent's exercise of ministry; (c) recommend to the Bishop Diocesan that the Respondent be admonished, suspended or deposed from ministry; (d) limit the involvement, attendance or participation of the Respondent in the Community; or (e) dismiss the matter; or (f) any combination of the foregoing. An Order providing for suspension from Ministry shall specify on what terms or conditions and at what time the suspension shall cease. Any Order providing for limitation upon the involvement, attendance or participation of the Respondent in the Community shall also provide conditions for restoration. Any Order dismissing the matter shall provide the reasons for dismissal and a statement exonerating the Respondent and shall be made available to members of the Church and the Church media in the same manner with which documents were initially made available to the public as set forth in Canon IV.13.3.

Citation: General Convention, Journal of the General Convention of...The Episcopal Church, Baltimore, 2022 (New York: General Convention, 2023), pp. 550-551, 822-823.

Legislative History

Author: The Rev. Lynn Carter-Edmands
Originating House: House of Bishops
Originating Committee: Title IV Disciplinary Canons

House of Bishops

The House of Bishops Committee on Title IV Disciplinary Canons presented its Report #10 on Resolution D040 (Amend Canons IV.13.4, IV 13.11.e, IV.13.13, and IV.14.6 [Document Dissemination, Appeal of Sanction, Of Hearing Panels, Order of Dismissal]) and moved to refer the resolution to an interim body.

Original Text of Resolution:

(D040)

Resolved, the House of Deputies concurring,

That the 80th General Convention amend Canon IV.13.4 to read as follows:

Sec. 4. If at any time after a matter has been referred to a Hearing Panel an Accord or Order of Dismissal endorsed by the Bishop Diocesan is reached that ends the proceedings before the Hearing Panel issues an Order, the Bishop Diocesan shall make the Notice of Accord or Order of Dismissal available to the Church and Church media as provided in Sec. 3 as well as to the Hearing Panel.

And be it further

Resolved, That Canon IV.13.11.e be amended to read as follows:

e. If an Accord is reached or the matter is dismissed that ends the proceedings before the Disciplinary Board issues an Order other than an Order of Dismissal under this Section, the Bishop Diocesan shall make the Notice of Accord or Order of Dismissal available to the Church and Church media as provided in Sec. 3 as well as to the Disciplinary Board and the Hearing Panel.

And be it further

Resolved, That Canon IV.13.13 be amended to read as follows:

Section 13.  If the determination is to dismiss the matter, the Hearing Panel shall issue an Order which shall include the reasons for dismissal and which contains may contain findings exonerating the Respondent.  A copy of the Order shall be provided to the Bishop Diocesan, the Respondent, the Respondent’s Advisor, the Complainant, the Complainant’s Advisor, and the Church Attorney, and a record copy of the Order shall be kept by transmitting a copy to The Archives of The Episcopal Church.  A copy of the Order shall also be made available to the Church and the Church media in the same manner with which documents were initially made available to the public as set forth in Sec. 3.

And be it further

Resolved, That IV.13.14 be removed in its entirety.

Sec. 14. If the resolution is the issuance of an Order other than an Order of dismissal, the provisions of Canon IV.14 shall apply.

And be it further

Resolved, That Canon IV.14.6 be amended to read as follows:

Sec. 6. An Order issued by a Conference Panel or Hearing Panel may (a) provide any terms which promote healing, repentance, forgiveness, restitution, justice, amendment of life and reconciliation among the Complainant, Respondent, affected Community and other persons; (b) place restrictions on the Respondent's exercise of ministry; (c) recommend to the Bishop Diocesan that the Respondent be admonished, suspended or deposed from ministry; (d) limit the involvement, attendance or participation of the Respondent in the Community; or (e) dismiss the matter; or (f) any combination of the foregoing. An Order providing for suspension from Ministry shall specify on what terms or conditions and at what time the suspension shall cease. Any Order providing for limitation upon the involvement, attendance or participation of the Respondent in the Community shall also provide conditions for restoration. Any Order dismissing the matter shall provide the reasons for dismissal and a statement exonerating the Respondent and shall be made available to members of the Church and the Church media in the same manner with which documents were initially made available to the public as set forth in Canon IV.13.3.

Motion carried

Resolution referred to an interim body

(Communicated to the House of Deputies in HB Message #175)

House of Deputies

The House of Deputies Committee on Title IV Disciplinary Canons presented its Report #40 on HB Message #175 on Resolution D040 (Amend Canons IV.13.4, IV 13.11.e, IV.13.13, and IV.14.6 [Document Dissemination, Appeal of Sanction, Of Hearing Panels, Order of Dismissal]) and moved concurrence with referral to an interim body.

Motion carried

The House concurred

Resolution referred

(Communicated to the House of Bishops in HD Message #292)

Resolution Referred to a Standing Commission by Both Houses.

Abstract:   The 80th General Convention refers to a Standing Commission a resolution amending Canons IV.13.4, IV.13.11(e), IV.13.13, and IV.14.6 to improve clarity where Orders of Dismissal are concerned.