Resolution Number: | 2012-A033 | |
---|---|---|
Title: | Amend Canons IV.2, 5, 6, 11 as follows: Canon IV.2 [Of Terminology Used in This Title] Canon IV.5.3(i) [Resource Sharing for Disciplinary Boards’ Rules of Operation] Canon IV.6.7 [Impanelment to Consider an Offense] Canon IV.11.5 [Confidentiality of Investigations] |
|
Legislative Action Taken: | Concurred as Amended | |
Final Text: |
Resolved, That the following sections of Canons IV.2, be amended to read as follows:
Advisor shall mean a person designated to support, assist,
consult with, advise and, where expressly so authorized under this
Title, speak for a Complainant or Respondent in any matter of
discipline under this Title, as provided in Canon
IV.19.10.
Complainant shall mean (a) theany person or
persons from whom the Intake Officer receives information concerning an alleged Offense and who, upon
consent of that person(s), is designated a Complainant by the Intake
Officer or (b) any Injured Person designated by the Bishop
Diocesan who, in the Bishop Diocesan’s discretion, should
be afforded the status of a Complainant, provided, however, that any Injured
Person so designated may decline such designation.
Conference Panel shall mean a panel of one,
two or threeor more members of the
Disciplinary Board selected by the president of the board, unless some other
manner of selection is provided by Diocesan Canon, to serve as the body before
which an informal conference is held as provided in Canon IV.12, provided,
however, that no such member of the Conference
Panel may serve as a member of the Hearing Panel in the same
case. The president of the Disciplinary Board shall be
ineligible to serve on the Conference Panel. If the Conference Panel consists
of more than one member, it shall include both clergy and lay
members.
Hearing Panel shall mean a panel of three or more members of the Disciplinary Board and shall include both clergy and lay members selected by the president of the Board, unless some other manner of selection is provided by Diocesan Canon, to serve as the body before which a hearing is held as provided in Canon IV.13, provided, however, that no such member of the Hearing Panelmay serve as a member of the Conference Panel in the same case. The president of the Disciplinary Board shall be ineligible to serve on the Hearing Panel.; and be it further
Resolved, that Canon IV.5.3 (i) be amended as follows:
(i) Any Diocese may agree in writing with one or more other Dioceses to develop and share resources necessary to implement this Title, including members of Disciplinary Boards, Church Attorneys, Intake Officers, Advisors, Investigators, Conciliators and administrative and financial support for proceedings under this Title.; and be it further
Resolved, that Canon IV.6.5, IV.6.7 and IV.6.8 be amended as follows:
Sec. 5. If the Intake Officer determines that the
information, if true, would not constitute an Offense, the Intake Officer shall
inform the Bishop Diocesan of an intention to dismiss the matter. If the Bishop
Diocesan does not object, the Intake Officer shall dismiss the matter. The
Intake Officer shall provide written notice to the Complainant and the Bishop
Diocesan of the decision of dismissal, the reasons therefor, and the
Complainant's right to appeal the decision within thirty days of the date of
the notice and shall send a copy of that notice and the written intake report
to the president of the Disciplinary Board. If the Complainant wishes to appeal
the dismissal, the Intake Officer shall assist the Complainant in preparing and
signing a written statement of the acts complained of, which statement shall be
sent to the president
of the Disciplinary Board,along with a statement
that the Complainant appeals the dismissal. The intake report and any related
information, in the case of a dismissal, mayshall be retained by the Intake Officer and may be considered in connection with any additional
information that may come to the Intake Officer thereafter concerning the
subject Member of the Clergy.
Sec. 7. If the Intake Officer determines that the
information, if true, would constitute an Offense, the Intake Officer shall
promptly forward the intake report to the Reference Panel. The president shall
promptly select from the Disciplinary Board, by lot or by other random
means, a Conference Panel and a Hearing Panel, and shall
designate a president of each Panel. A Conference Panel may
consist of one or more person. A Hearing Panel shall consist of not less than
three persons and shall include both clergy and lay members. The president
shall be ineligible to serve on either Panel.
Sec. 8. The Reference Panel shall meet as soon as possible after receiving the intake report to determine how to refer the report. Referral options are (a) no action required other than appropriate pastoral response pursuant to Canon IV.8; (b) conciliation pursuant to Canon IV.10; (c) investigation pursuant to Canon IV.11; (d) to the Conference Panel pursuant to Canon IV.12; or (e)referral for possible agreement with the Bishop Diocesan regarding terms of discipline pursuant to Canon IV.9. Referral decisions shall require the approval of a majority of the Reference Panel.; and be it further
Resolved, that Canon IV.7.11 be amended as follows:
Sec. 11. If a request for review of restriction on ministry
or Administrative Leave is made prior to referral to the Conference Panel, then
the review shall be conducted by the Conference Panel. If a request for review
of restriction on ministry or Administrative Leave is made subsequent to
referral to the Conference Panel but prior to referral to the Hearing Panel,
the review shall be conducted by the Conference Panel. If a request for review
of restriction on ministry or Administrative Leave is made subsequent to
referral to the Hearing Panel, the review shall be conducted by the Hearing
Panel. The question before a Panel reviewing a restriction on ministry or
Administrative Leave is whether, at the time of the review and based upon
information then available to the Panel, the restrictions on ministry or
Administrative Leave and the terms and conditions thereof are warranted. The
review may be conducted either personally or telephonically. The Intake
Officer, the Respondent, or the Respondent's Advisor, the Respondent's counsel, if
any,or both, the Bishop Diocesan,
the Chancellor and the Church Attorney shall each be afforded the opportunity
to be present, either personally or telephonically, at the review, and any such
person present shall be heard by the Panel if such person desires to be heard.
The Panel may hear from other persons at the Panel's discretion.; and be it
further
Resolved, that Canon IV.8.2 and IV.8.3 be amended as follows:
Sec. 2. In each pastoral response the Bishop Diocesan shall
consider offering pastoral care to all those who may be affected
by the an alleged Offense.or allegations thereof. Pastoral care
shall be considered for the Complainant, the Complainant's family, the
Respondent, the Respondent's family, Injured Persons, Injured Persons'
families, any affected Community, witnesses, and the Disciplinary
Board.
Sec. 3. In every case, and notwithstanding any other
provision of this Title to the contrary, the Bishop Diocesan may disclose such
information concerning any alleged Offense or allegations thereof or concerning any
Accord or Order as the Bishop Diocesan deems pastorally appropriate.;and be it
further
Resolved, that Canon IV.9 be amended by adding a new Section 4 as follows:
Sec. 4. Accords under this Section shall be subject to all the provisions of Canon IV.14 regarding Accords, not inconsistent with this Section.; and be it further
Resolved, that Canons IV.11.3 and IV.11.5 be amended as follows:
Sec. 3. The Investigator shall present the findings of the
investigation in writing to the Reference Panel. The Reference Panel may meet
with the Investigator and shall consider the report to determine whether to (a)
take no action other than appropriate pastoral responses pursuant to Canon
IV.8; (b) refer the matter to the Bishop Diocesan for consideration of
proceedings under Canon IV.9; (c) refer the matter to conciliation pursuant to
Canon IV.10; (d) require further investigation; or (e) refer the matter to the
Conference Panel pursuant to Canon IV.12,or to the Hearing Panel pursuant to Canon IV.13. The
determination shall be approved by a majority vote of the Reference Panel.
Sec. 5. All investigations shall be confidential except until such time as information obtained may be
utilized by the Church Attorney, the Bishop Diocesan or the Panels upon the consent of the person interviewed or as the Bishop
Diocesan deems pastorally necessary, and all.
All pPersons, prior to being interviewed by the
investigator,shall be advised of the confidential
nature of the investigation and when such information may be
shared during the course of the proceedings.; and be it
further
Resolved, that Canon IV.12.3, IV.12.4, IV.12.7, IV.12.8 and IV.12.12 be amended as follows:
Sec. 3. The Conference Panel shall issue a notice to the
Respondent, the Respondent’s Advisor,the
Respondent’s counsel, if any,the Complainant,
the Complainant’s Advisor, the Investigator and such other persons, if
any, as the Conference Panel in its discretion may determine. The notice shall
describe the nature and purpose of the proceeding, shall contain a copy of the written statement prepared by the Church Attorney, shall
disclose the names of all persons to whom the notice is sent, and shall
establish a date, time and place for conference at which the Respondent is to
appear before the Conference Panel, which date shall be not less than
twenty days after service of the notice upon the Respondent.
Sec. 4. The Respondent shall attend the conference and may be accompanied by an Advisor or counsel, if any, or
both.
Sec. 7. The proceedings of the Conference Panel shall be
informal and conversational. The Conference Panel shall describe the alleged
Offense to the Respondent. The Conference Panel shall hear from the Complainant
or the Complainant's Advisor or both, if either or both are present, and from
the Respondent orand the Respondent's Advisor or
counsel, if any, or both. At its discretion, the Conference
Panel may hear from the Investigator or any other persons present, and may
direct the Investigator to conduct additional investigation and suspend its
proceedings to allow such investigation to be completed. At its discretion, the
Conference Panel may confer with any participants outside the presence of the
other participants.
Sec. 8. No witnesses shall be called to testify at the proceedings before
the Conference Panel. No record of the proceedings of the Conference Panel
shall be made. The conference shall be closed to all except the members of the
Conference Panel and invited participants. Proceedings before the Conference
Panel shall be confidential except as may be provided in an Order or Accord or
as provided elsewhere in this Title. No statements made by
any participant in such proceeding may be used as evidence before the Hearing
Panel.
Sec. 12. The Respondent or the Church Attorney may refuseobject to an
Order issued by the Conference Panel by giving written notice of the refusalobjection to
the president of the Conference Panel within fifteen days following the
effective date of the Order as defined in Canon IV.14.10. Upon receipt of the
notice of refusalobjection, the president of the Conference Panel shall
notify the president of the Disciplinary Board of the refusalobjection and the matter will proceed as provided in Canon IV.14.11.; and be it
further
Resolved, that Canon IV.13.2 and IV.13.5 (d) be amended as follows:
Sec. 2. Upon receipt of a referral for Hearing Panel
proceedings, the Church Attorney shall review all information acquired as of
the time of such referral and, if necessary, shall revise or update the
statement of the alleged Offense and shall
provide the same to the Hearing Panel. The Hearing Panel shall issue a notice
to the Respondent, to the Respondent's Advisor, to
Respondent’s counsel, if any, and to the Church
Attorney.
Sec. 5. The Church Attorney and the Respondent shall each be afforded reasonable time and opportunity to prepare evidence for the hearing as follows:
(d) Discovery procedures as approved in
the discovery plan filed pursuant to Canon IV.13.5(a) may include written interrogatories,
oral or written deposition testimony of any person having knowledge pertaining
to the alleged Offense or any
defenses, thereto,requests for
production of documents or tangible objects, and requests for
admissions of fact.;and be it further
Resolved, that Canon IV.14.4, IV.14.5, IV.14.11, and IV.14.12 be amended as follows:
Sec. 4. A copy of the Accord shall be sent to the Complainant, the
Complainant's Advisor, the Respondent, the Respondent's
Advisor, the Respondent’s counsel,
if any, the Church Attorney and the Bishop Diocesan by the
Conciliator or the president of the Conference Panel or Hearing Panel
(whichever the matter was before when the Accord was reached) on the date that
the Conciliator or president of the Panel signs the Accord. If the
Accord was reached between the Bishop Diocesan and Respondent under Canon IV.9,
the Bishop Diocesan shall send a copy of the Accord to the persons listed in
this Section on the date the Accord becomes effective and
irrevocable.
Sec. 5. The Bishop Diocesan shall have thirty days from the
date on which the Accord is sent to the Bishop Diocesan in which to advise in
writing the Respondent, the Respondent's Advisor,the
Respondent’s counsel, if any, the Complainant, the
Complainant's Advisor, the Church Attorney and the Conciliator or the president
of the Conference Panel or Hearing Panel whether the Bishop Diocesan will
pronounce the Sentence or accept the other terms of the Accord as recommended.
The Bishop Diocesan shall advise that he or she will (a) pronounce the Sentence
as recommended or (b) pronounce a lesser Sentence than that recommended and/or
(c) reduce the burden on the Respondent of any of the other terms of the
Accord. The Bishop Diocesan shall pronounce Sentence not sooner than forty days
following the date on which the Accord is sent to the Bishop Diocesan and not
later than sixty days following such date. The Bishop Diocesan's pronouncement
of a lesser Sentence than that recommended or other modification shall not
affect the validity or enforceability of the remainder of the Accord. In the case of an Accord under Canon IV.9, the Bishop
Diocesan shall pronounce Sentence not sooner than
the day after the date the Accord became effective and irrevocable.
Sec. 11. If the Order is issued by a Conference Panel, the
Respondent may refuseobject
to the Order as provided in Canon IV.12.12 and the
matter shall be referred to a Hearing Panel for hearing as provided in Canon
IV.13.
Sec. 12. If there has been
no objection by the Respondent, notice of Accords and Orders which shall have become effective and are not subject to refusal by
the Respondent shall be given without delay as
follows:
(a) In the case of any Accord or Order pertaining to a Priest or Deacon,
the Bishop Diocesan shall give notice of the Accord or Order to every Member of
the Clergy in the Diocese, each Vestry in the Diocese, the Secretary of
Convention, and the Standing Committee of the Diocese, which shall be added to
the official records of the Diocese; to the Presiding Bishop, to all other
Bishops of the Church, and where there is no Bishop, to the Ecclesiastical
Authority of each Diocese of the Church; to the Recorder of ordinations; to
the Church Deployment OfficeOffice of Transition Ministry; the Archives; and to the
Secretary of the House of Bishops and the Secretary of the House of Deputies.; and be it further
Resolved, that Canon IV.14 be amended by adding a new section IV.14.13 as follows:
Sec. 13. In every case, notwithstanding any other provision of this Title to the contrary, the Bishop Diocesan may disclose such information concerning any Offense or allegations thereof or concerning any Accord or Order as the Bishop Diocesan deems appropriate.; and be it further
Resolved, that Canon IV.19 be amended as follows:
Sec. 10. Each Diocese shall make provision for Advisors to be available to Respondents and Complainants as provided in this Canon for the purposes of support, assistance, consultation and advice regarding the process provided in this Title and the rights, responsibilities, consequences and alternatives pertaining thereto.
(a) The Bishop Diocesan shall make an Advisor available to
the Respondent not later than the earliest of (1) reference for conciliation,
to the Conference Panel or to the Hearing Panel, (2) the imposition of
restriction on ministry or placement on Administrative Leave, or (3)the Respondent or
Bishop Diocesan proposing terms of discipline to the other under Canon IV.9, or
(4) any interrogation or request for a statement or other
information from the Respondent.
(b) The Bishop Diocesan shall make an Advisor available to
the Complainant not later than the earliest of (1) the forwarding of the intake
report to the Reference Panel, (2) the Complainant's appeal of a dismissal
under Canon IV.6.5, or (3) the Respondent or Bishop Diocesan proposing terms of discipline to
the other under Canon IV.9, or (4) the Bishop's designation
of an Injured Person as a Complainant.;and be it further
Resolved, that Canon IV.19.22 be amended as follows:
Sec. 22. A Hearing Panel,Disciplinary Board or Court of Review may in
its discretion obtain legal counsel to give it or the
President of the Board or one of its Panels opinions on any
questions of law, procedure or evidence. Such legal counsel, if any, shall have
no vote in any proceeding before the Hearing PanelDisciplinary Board, one
of its Panels, or Court of Review.; and be it further
Resolved, that Canon I.9.8 be amended as follows:
Sec. 8. The Provincial Synod shall have power: (a) to enact Ordinances
for its own regulation and government; (b) to elect
judges of the Provincial Court of
Review; (c)(b) to perform such duties as many be committed to it by the General
Convention; (d)(c) to deal with all matters within the Province; Provided, however, that no
Provincial Synod shall have power to regulate or control the internal policy or
affairs of any constituent Diocese; and Provided, further, that all
actions and proceedings of the Synod shall be subject to and in conformity with
the provisions of the Constitution and the Canons for the government of this
Church; (e)(d)to
adopt a budget for the maintenance of any Provincial work undertaken by the
Synod, such budget to be raised in such manner as the Synod may
determine; (f)(e) to create
by Ordinance a provincial Council with power to administer and carry on such
work as may be committed to it by the General Convention, or by the Presiding
Bishop and the Executive Council, or by the Synod of the Province.
Citation: | General Convention, Journal of the General Convention of...The Episcopal Church, Indianapolis, 2012 (New York: General Convention, 2012), pp. 293-298. |
---|